The Dallas Cowboys have displayed an uncanny lack of ability to play complementary football this season. It is the same story every week: X side of the ball plays incredibly well while X side of the ball lets them down. In the past few weeks, the offense underperformed. This week, it was the opposite.
Dak Prescott threw for 343 yards and five touchdowns, hanging 40 points on one of the NFL's best defenses. And the Cowboys lost! After weeks of showing improvement, Christian Parker's defense allowed 46 points and a whopping 584 yards of offense. Some teams don't get that in two games.
Last week, when they narrowly defeated the lowly Indianapolis Colts, Dallas fooled some folks in the post-Week 9 power rankings. And they did so again after their Week 10 loss to the San Francisco 49ers, as America's Team somehow moved up.
Dallas Cowboys
FanSided - Jason La Canfora
Current - 20
Last Week - 21
"The offense showed real verve and spark and they did it without CeeDee Lamb doing anything until very late in the game. The defense got after Brock Purdy some. The bar is set so dang low in the NFC East that giving up a near fifty-burger at home gets you a mild uptick. All the teams in this region of the power rankings stink."
Our take: Moving up after that loss certainly feels like a choice. Yes, the Cowboys' offense once again proved that it is a juggernaut, and perhaps that is a bigger vote of confidence than it feels like. But this team is going nowhere fast with this defense, and sitting at No. 20 feels incredibly generous.
Current - 20
Last Week - 20
"Non-QB MVP at midseason: DT Quinnen Williams
"Considering the porous nature of the Cowboys' defense, it's difficult to say a player on that unit deserves this honor, but that's how well Williams has played. He leads the team with six sacks, the most for a Dallas defensive tackle in a season since 2017, and is second in QB pressures. Williams leads the NFL with 15 tackles for loss and is tied for fifth with three forced fumbles. He is doing everything he can to raise the level of play on defense. He just needs more help." -- Todd Archer
Our take: Yeah, Quinnen Williams is awesome, as he's overcome an early-season lull to anchor the Dallas... Can you call it a defense? No. 20 feels quite kind, once again, but there aren't many teams behind the Cowboys worthy of this spot. And a close loss to the 49ers is a close loss to the 49ers.
NFL.com - Nick Shook
Current - 18
Last Week - 22
"We knew the Cowboys’ defense couldn’t stop a nosebleed. We knew their offensive firepower represented their only chance of success. Dallas seemingly acknowledged this reality, too, with Sunday’s performance against San Francisco. This offense remains good enough (in most weeks) to keep the 'Boys in the playoff hunt, but the defense won’t ever give them a real chance of winning anything significant without some changes. It just is what it is."
Our take: For weeks, Shook's initial statement did not seem to be the case. But Week 10 was another reminder that the Cowboys' offense is elite and that significant changes must be made on defense, whatever they are. The NFC East is wide open, though, as Shook says. Let's see what they can do.
No. 18 does feel way too high, though.
Fox Sports - Ralph Vacchiano
Current - 20
Last Week - 20
"There is something terribly wrong with this franchise. Can they really not see how big of a mess their defense is? Do they really want to keep the status quo going after giving up 584 yards to the 49ers? The Cowboys' offense was late to the party in Week 10, but at least it showed up. Unfortunately, every time Dak Prescott got the Cowboys back in the game, his own defense thwarted his comeback. They’ve got a lot of work to do this offseason to try and fix this mess."
Our take: To be fair, the defense was a bit better there for a while, until the wheels fell off the wagon in Week 10. The Dallas offense does need to start faster, and in totality, the team is a mess, but this offense may just be good enough to cloak that and keep them in the hunt for the NFC East.
Who knows?
The Athletic - Josh Kendall and Chad Graff
Current - 19
Last Week - 17
"Breakout player: Ryan Flournoy
"The third-year wide receiver, a sixth-round pick in 2024, has found a role even with CeeDee Lamb and George Pickens getting most of the targets. Flournoy had six catches for 71 yards and a touchdown Sunday and is on the doorstep of a career year with seven games left. He has 38 receptions for 466 yards this season.
Our take: Cowboys fans knew about Flournoy long before he hit the national spotlight, but it is nice to see him getting his flowers. When the offense is clicking, as it was in Week 10, there is room for everyone to eat.
Sports Illustrated - Conor Orr
Current - 26
Last Week - 27
"Brian Schottenheimer wouldn’t commit to the status quo at defensive coordinator and, while I feel like it’s a pile-on festival with Christian Parker at this point, I’m not sure that he can last much longer without a major riot on behalf of the fan base at this point."
Our take: For as high as some of these rankings feel, No. 26 is too low. That said, Orr is right to point out that a move could be made here soon at defensive coordinator, and perhaps deservedly so. It will be interesting to see, if that happens, whether or not it is the jolt that Dallas badly needs.
Current - 19
Last Week - 20
"The story remains the same for the Dallas Cowboys. The offense can consistently move the ball and score points, but the defense remains a constant source of disappointment.
"The San Francisco 49ers offense amassed a staggering 584 yards during Sunday's meeting. It's the most the team has accumulated during the Kyle Shanahan era, according to NBC Sports Bay Area's Matt Maiocco. The output was the most Dallas ever surrendered during a home game.
"Once again, the Cowboys rank last in total defense. As The Ringer's Sheil Kapadia noted, the unit is also dead last in EPA per drive for the second straight season. Sadly, the Dallas offense is fun to watch but continues to be wasted, because the Cowboys somehow can't find a way to even slow an opponent."
Our take: A slight bump is perhaps appropriate after a close loss to the NFL's best team. And the story that they're outlining is not entirely accurate, but something does need to be done about the defense, and the offense has to maintain or at least approach its pace from last Sunday.
Average Rank -
Average Rank Last Week - 21.0
Change -
Highest Rank -
Lowest Rank -
Biggest Change -
