Skip to main content

Brandon Aubrey’s stunning regression is becoming a familiar Cowboys nightmare

The Cowboys have a Brandon Aubrey issue on their hands.
ByRichard Louis
Dallas Cowboys kicker Brandon Aubrey
Dallas Cowboys kicker Brandon Aubrey | IMAGN IMAGES via Reuters Connect

The Dallas Cowboys lost to the San Francisco 49ers 46-40 in a high-scoring affair on Sunday. This dropped the Cowboys to 4-6, and there are multiple players to blame for the loss.

And while kicker Brandon Aubrey isn't the biggest culprit, his falloff this season can't be understated. After looking like one of the best kickers in the league, Aubrey has looked anything but that in 2026. No matter what is said, the Cowboys now have a kicker problem on their hands.

Cowboys have a big Brandon Aubrey problem on their hands despite record-breaking deal

During the loss to the 49ers, Aubrey went 2-of-2 on field goals, but went 2-of-3 on extra points. In the second quarter, receiver George Pickens scored a 39-yard touchdown, but Aubrey missed the extra point. Instead of giving the Cowboys a seven-point lead, Aubrey missed it left, which sucked the life out of a moment worthy of celebration.

This has been the story this season for Dallas' kicker.

In 2026, he is 19-of-24 (79 percent) on field goal attempts and 25-of-27 on extra point attempts. The Cowboys used to lean on Aubrey's leg, especially from distance, but that is no longer the case. He's 5-of-10 on kicks from 50-plus yards away, as he's no longer automatic.

Last season was when his struggles from 50-plus yards away started. Aubrey went 11-of-17 from kicks 50+, and those inconsistencies have spilled over into this campaign.

The worst part is that Dallas gave Aubrey a four-year, $28 million deal, with 20 million guaranteed this past offseason. That made him the highest-paid kicker in the league, yet his play on the field has been that of a below-average kicker.

He's the most recent example of a player who got extended by Dallas, and his production dipped immediately after.

Cowboys are used to players falling off right after getting extended

Cornerback Daron Bland got a four-year, $92 million deal in Aug. 2025, and his play hasn't matched that price tag. This season alone has been one of the worst in his career. Bland hasn't been able to slow down receivers he's lined up against, and teams have found success throwing his way.

According to Pro Football Focus, Bland has a 41.1 coverage grade (95th among 103 graded CBs). Take these grades with a grain of salt, but Bland isn't passing the eye test either. Per PFF, Bland is eighth among CBs in receiving yards allowed (424) on 34 catches and four touchdowns in 2026.

Another player we can discuss is tight end Jake Ferguson. He got a four-year, $52 million extension in July 2025. After signing that deal, he posted a career-best 600 receiving yards and eight touchdowns last season, but that success has quickly faded in 2026.

This season, Ferguson has been an afterthought. Over nine games, he has 19 catches for 136 receiving yards and four touchdowns. He's averaging just 15.1 receiving yards per game, and that's nowhere near good enough for the ninth-highest-paid tight end in the league.

Bland and Ferguson were two players who were pinpointed as building blocks for this team, and neither guy is living up to the status. And neither is Aubrey.

Former Cowboys kicker Dan Bailey was someone else who got paid by the team and fell off a cliff. From 2011 to 2014, Bailey went 89-of-98 (90 percent) on field goal attempts and a perfect 123-of-123 on extra-point kicks.

That led to him getting a seven-year, $22.5 million extension in 2014. He then had a Pro Bowl campaign in 2016, but things went off track after that. In 2016, his field goal percentage went to 84 percent (27-of-32) before dropping again in 2017 to 75 percent (15-of-20). That led to his release.

These are three examples of the Cowboys handing out lucrative extensions only to watch those players regress. Dallas can't afford to turn a blind eye to what's happening with Aubrey.

He's no longer performing at the elite level that earned him his extension, and while his track record warrants some patience, his recent struggles are becoming too difficult to ignore.

Add us as a preferred source on Google