I might be starting to sound like a broken record, but the Dallas Cowboys once again came up short against an opponent with a winning record, falling 46-40 to the San Francisco 49ers on Sunday.
Yes, that's a real final score.
This game had all the hits. Inept defense. Fireworks on offense. Brian Schotteneheimer getting outclassed by the guy on the opposite sideline. Dak Prescott playing at a high level and it not mattering. All familiar stuff.
The Cowboys are now 4-6 on the year. They have two winnable games up next against Tennessee and Philadelphia, giving them a great chance to pull even at 6-6 going into December. That would leave them with a shot to catch the Giants in the NFC East, but does it matter?
Sunday's loss at AT&T Stadium was deflating, as it served as another reminder that Dallas doesn't belong anywhere near the playoffs. Let's get into some instant reactions.
Instant reactions to the Cowboys' Week 10 loss to the 49ers
Christian Parker should lose his job
The general sentiment coming in was that Kyle Shanahan would turn AT&T Stadium into his playground. It took two quarters for his offense to show up, but the final numbers paint the most damning picture yet for Christian Parker.
46 points. Highest single-game yardage total of any team this season (584). The second-most yards the Cowboys have allowed in their 66-year history. 9.4 yards per play. 214 rushing yards. 6-of-11 third downs. Touchdowns of 74 yards, 70 yards and 66 yards.
At some point, the Cowboys have to ask themselves what they're getting out of keeping Parker around. The Joneses can point to Parker's inexperience and the unrelenting wave of injuries in the secondary, but what more do they need to see? We're 10 games in, and Dallas has absolutely no chance on defense in most matchups.
The offense put up 40 points on Sunday, and it didn't matter. The Cowboys can't afford to let Parker grow on the job. They grossly miscalculated by thinking he was ready to be a DC.
Don't be fooled by the Cowboys' first half
The Cowboys probably surprised a lot of folks by hanging with San Francisco in the first half. The two teams traded blows on offense. Dallas' defense won at the line of scrimmage and consistently made Brock Purdy uncomfortable in the pocket.
Was it enough to buy that America's Team is for real? Of course not. Any team can hang tough with a superior opponent for 30 minutes. Playing at home, a serious team would have pushed the 49ers to the brink.
Brian Schottenheimer's team, though, let go of the rope in the second half, allowing touchdowns on three straight drives to start the second half to go up 38-19.
The first half was really fun. But it was so misleading. A roster as talented as Dallas' can compete with most squads. At some point, though, the coaching disadvantage was going to rear its ugly head.
And that's precisely what happened in the second half, when Kyle Shanahan came out of the locker room with a bevy of adjustments up his sleeve, while Schottenheimer was caught flat-footed by Raheem Morris' halftime tweaks.
Speaking of the Cowboys' head coach ...
Brian Schottenheimer is his own worst enemy
When looking back on why/how Dallas lost, Schottenheimer’s decision to punt on 4th-and-2 at the end of the first half looms very large. While the offense was at its own 43-yard line, it was also 2-for-2 on fourth downs at that point in the game. George Pickens was unrecoverable. The offensive line was winning the battle in the trenches.
Did the 49ers punish Schottenheimer by scoring to end the half? No, but that’s not the point. This was another example of Schottenheimer not having a read on the game. At this point, it’s just fair to accept that he’s never going to push the envelope.
The Cowboys trailed 16-17 at the time and the defense had allowed a 73-yard broken-play touchdown on the previous drive. You could feel that the dam was going to break at some point, and it did, as his defense allowed a five-play, 81-yard TD drive to start the third quarter.
One would think that Schottenheimer would learn from that. Nope. He settled for another 52-yard field goal rather than chase points to make the score 24-19. Congrats. You made a one-score game a one-score game.
Finally, Schottenheimer was punished in the form of a Deebo Samuel 70-yard rushing touchdown. Just like that, Dallas trailed 31-19.
The defense remains a massive issue, but that is also why Schottenheimer needs to be more aggressive. He continues to coach as though he has a defense that can protect a lead and an offense that needs to be protected from itself. The reality is the exact opposite.
And speaking of Mr. Aubrey ...
Brandon Aubrey might be broken
Aubrey’s efficiency on long field goals has fallen off a cliff this season. In his defense, though, he’s still attempting more kicks from beyond 50 yards than anyone in the league. If anything, more of the blame belonged to Brian Schottenheimer for failing to adjust to his kicker’s regression.
I've maintained that I'll start to worry about Aubrey when he starts misfiring on shorter kicks. Well, in the second quarter, the NFL's highest-paid kicker missed an extra point for the second time this season.
Not only did it take some of the air out of George Pickens' touchdown, but it also had immediate consequences. The 49ers scored a touchdown on their ensuing possession to take a 17-16 lead, leaving the Cowboys playing from behind because of a missed extra point.
Aubrey drilled a pair of 52-yard field goals in the game, but when you're making $7 million per year, you can't be leaving points on the board with missed extra points, let alone in a game of this magnitude.
It’s fair to wonder, at this point, if Aubrey will ever rediscover the form that made him a superstar at the position. He’s a shell of that guy.
Enough of KaVontae Turpin on offense
The Cowboys sent a loud message to start the game, as Camden Brown and Israel Abanikanda, the RB2 today with Tyler Goodson (knee) being placed on IR, were the starting kickoff returners.
Kristi Scales reported before kickoff that Brown and Abanikanda would handle kickoff duties, while Turpin would assume his role as the lead punt returner. While this marked Turpin’s first game back from a rib injury, the kickoff return operation was efficient in his absence.
Could Dallas be laying the groundwork to lessen Turpin’s role? If so, he didn’t make a strong case on offense as he dropped his first target of the game on 1st-and-10. He was wider than wide open in the flat on first down. He might not have had enough room to move the chains, but he would have gotten at least seven yards by just running straight.
Ryan Flournoy was not on the field. My question: why are we taking away snaps from Ryan Flournoy to design plays for Turpin, who’s hardly known for his soft hands? It didn’t come back to haunt the offense, but any Turpin targets in the passing game feel like wasted effort.
More bad coaching. Schottenheimer should know his personnel better at this point in his tenure.
Losses might be better for Dallas' future
If you're in the camp that Schottenheimer is in over his head, you should probably be rooting for losses. Now, that is easier said than done once the ball is kicked off -- and especially as Dallas mounted a fourth-quarter comeback -- but the best thing for this franchise might be missing out on the playoffs in a terrible year for the division.
That would almost certainly guarantee that Schottenheimer is fired. And that would at least offer hope that the Joneses would hire a head coach capable of maximizing this roster.
Sneaking into the playoffs by virtue of a historically weak NFC East might be the worst thing that could happen to this franchise. It would give the Joneses all the justification they need to run it back with Schottenheimer, when the Cowboys should be setting their sights much higher than simply winning a bad division.
Through a season and a half at the helm, Schottenheimer has only put together one winning streak -- against the Chiefs and Eagles last year. They haven't beaten a team with a winning record since they erased a 21-point deficit against the Eagles last season.
Dak Prescott has not missed a game in Schottenheimer's time as head coach. Yes, this has all coincided with a defensive rebuild, but as the head coach, Schottenheimer deserves to bear a good chunk of the struggles on that side of the ball.
The Cowboys will continue to toil in mediocrity as long as Schottenheimer is running the show.
