Skip to main content

Grading Dak Prescott's Week 10: Cowboys QB can't catch a break

Dak did what he could to beat the Niners, but the Dallas defense once again couldn't do its job.
ByLuke Norris
Dallas Cowboys quarterback Dak Prescott drops back to pass against the San Francisco 49ers; Kevin Jairaj
Dallas Cowboys quarterback Dak Prescott drops back to pass against the San Francisco 49ers; Kevin Jairaj | IMAGN IMAGES via Reuters Connect

Coming off a Week 9 matchup in which they needed a late touchdown drive just to get past the two-win Indianapolis Colts, a win that upped their record to 4-5, the Dallas Cowboys had a chance to get back to .500 and to gain ground on the NFC East-leading New York Giants in Week 10.

The big problem, of course, was that America's Team was facing the rival San Francisco 49ers, who came into the contest tied with the Buffalo Bills for the best record in the entire NFL at 7-1. And unlike the Cowboys, they're fantastic on both sides of the football.

As he's been doing for the vast majority of the season, Dak Prescott did his part in putting Dallas in position to win with what we have zero problem calling an "A" performance, throwing for a season-high 343 yards and tying a career best with five touchdown passes.

Admittedly, it certainly wasn't his most efficient day, as he completed just 58.8 percent of his 51 throws, which is why we couldn't give him a perfect "A+" grade. But again, he's basically the only reason the Cowboys even had a chance to win this football game, as he took it to a stout San Francisco defense, albeit in a 46-40 loss.

The defense, on the other hand, while it played solidly over the first 30 minutes, once again ran out of gas in the second half and ultimately surrendered 584 total yards to the Niners' offense, which marks the highest total by any visiting team in any home game in Cowboys history.

So, it really shouldn't surprise anyone that first-year defensive coordinator Christian Parker has had his play-calling duties taken away, with senior defensive assistant Mike Pettine set to take over.

Dak Prescott did everything he could to keep Cowboys within striking distance of 49ers

Now, what also shouldn't surprise anyone is that, despite posting the numbers that he did and keeping the Cowboys within striking distance of San Francisco after the Niners took a 38-19 lead early in the fourth quarter on a 16-yard touchdown run by Christian McCaffrey, Prescott is still being blamed by some for the loss, while others are saying that the only reason he posted those numbers is because he got the "garbage time" opportunity to do so.

Look, everyone is entitled to say what they like. But in this writer's humble opinion, those arguments themselves fall into the "garbage" category.

Say what you will about Dak, but the guy competes each and every week and has done so for 11 years now. And with this team, he knows the weapons he has, and that this Dallas offense can put up points in a hurry.

So, even with the Cowboys down by 19, he didn't let up and led three touchdown drives down the stretch. And it's somehow his fault that scoring 40 points on a good defense isn't enough? Seriously, someone explain that to me.

And as far as the "garbage time" stats are concerned, come on. Was it "garbage time" last Thanksgiving when he led the Cowboys back from a 21-point deficit to beat the Philadelphia Eagles? No. It was just a matter of him doing everything possible to try and get his team a win. It worked that time, and it didn't this time. It's seriously that simple.

Was Prescott perfect? No, he wasn't. The one interception he threw on fourth down in the third quarter could have been avoided had he simply run for a first down, as he did seemingly have the space to do so. But that's the only really big mistake he made, and San Francisco marching 90 yards down the field on the ensuing possession obviously can't be pinned on him. At least not reasonably anyway, as some are still trying to somehow do so.

With the loss, Dak became only the 13th quarterback ever to lose a game in which he threw for five or more touchdowns and one or fewer interceptions. So, that's fun.

And just to take things a step further, from his rookie year in 2016 to 2025, the Cowboys were 51-7-1 when scoring at least 30 points in games he started. But this year, they're just 3-3. And this is a Prescott problem? Come on now.

Add us as a preferred source on Google