It remains baffling the the Dallas Cowboys hired Brian Schottenheimer on a late Friday night. For an organization that typically embraces the spotlight, announcing such a consequential hire right before the weekend instead of first thing Monday morning felt telling. It suggested Jerry and Stephen Jones knew exactly how it would be received and wanted to limit exposure.
Sure enough, the move was met with seemingly universal criticism. Much of the backlash stemmed from Dallas' backwards process rather than Schottenheimer himself, but if you had polled 100 Cowboys fans on who they thought would replace Mike McCarthy, very few -- if any -- would have said Schottenheimer.
Remarkably, it didn't take long for Schottenheimer to curry favor with Cowboys fans, and his debut season has already turned doubters within the NFL into believers.
FanSided NFL insider Jason La Canfora recently spoke to a longtime personnel executive who applauded the job Schottenheimer did in Year 1.
“The head coach answered a lot of questions last year,” the exec said. “He had to deal with all of bullshit going back to last summer [Micah Parsons dealt and more contract unrest], and he shut a lot of people up. Including me.”
How about that?
Dallas Cowboys head coach Brian Schottenheimer is already proving NFL doubters wrong
Schottenheimer obviously has room for improvement. His play-calling in the red zone often got too cute, and he seemed content to lean on all-world kicker Brandon Aubrey once the offense crossed midfield instead of trusting his high-powered unit to finish drives with touchdowns.
There were too many instances where Schottenheimer coached not to lose instead of going for the jugular. Conservative football has its place when you can lean on an elite defense. The 2025 Cowboys didn't have that luxury. They fielded one of the worst defenses in franchise history, yet Schotty frequently managed games as if he could count on that unit to manufacture stops.
These are legitimate flaws, but they're also the kinds of flaws that a rookie head coach can reasonably outgrow. And the positives significantly outweigh the negatives.
Cowboys fans' biggest gripe with Mike McCarthy was his outdated scheme. Schottenheimer completely revolutionized Dallas' offense by embracing modern trends like pre-snap motion, disguised concepts, and tempo and meshing them with old-school tendencies.
Brian Schotteheimer clearly learned from his time coaching under Mike McCarthy
While Klayton Adams deserves much of the credit for the rushing attack, Schottenheimer understands how to marry the run and pass. That was often missing under Mike McCarthy, whose running game never really felt like an extension of the offense.
Nobody would mistake Schottenheimer for a top-five offensive mind, but the Cowboys are in great hands as long as the 53-year-old is designing the offense.
Oh, and we haven't even gotten to the Christian Parker hire. Schottenheimer spearheaded the defensive coordinator search and was instrumental in building Parker's coaching staff, which has earned widespread praise. Chalk up another win for Schotty.
Which brings us to Schottenheimer's ability to lead and rally a locker room. As the executive noted, he navigated the Micah Parsons trade like a seasoned coach and earned widespread praise for guiding the team through the Marshawn Kneeland tragedy.
There is a different energy and belief around the Dallas Cowboys right now, and Schottenheimer deserves much of the credit. The skepticism that greeted his hiring has given way to genuine optimism, and it's no longer coming solely from Cowboys fans.
Add us as a preferred source on Google