We've all come to the painful realization that the Dallas Cowboys' defensive personnel (and coaching staff) were overrated coming into the season. Would having Jalen Thompson, P.J. Locke, Malachi Lawrence and Donovan Ezeiruaku available have made a difference against the 49ers? Maybe a little, but those absences were out of Dallas' control.
What the Cowboys could control, however, was DeMarvion Overshown's playing time. The fourth-year linebacker returned from a one-game absence, only to play five defensive snaps despite being available.
It's hard to view that as anything other than punishment for his boneheaded decision to run onto the field in street clothes to celebrate a forced fumble against the Colts, drawing a 15-yard unsportsmanlike conduct penalty.
Part of me wants to applaud Schottenheimer for holding Overshown accountable for such a reckless mistake, but did the punishment really fit the crime? George Pickens and CeeDee Lamb were benched for only the opening drive against the Raiders last year after missing curfew.
Meanwhile, Overshown was effectively sidelined for an entire game while Kyle Shanahan put the Cowboys' linebackers in a blender.
DeMarvion Overshown's benching couldn't have happened at a worse time
There's no way to know how much of a difference Overshown would have made, but isn't he the Cowboys' best linebacker when healthy? He's far from a flawless player, but his ability to get downhill, finish tackles and hold his own in coverage makes him arguably the most well-rounded linebacker on the roster.
Despite that, Shemar James played every defensive snap, while Dee Winters was on the field for 58 of 65 defensive plays, per Pro Football Focus. Both finished among Dallas' lowest-graded defenders, which is saying something given how thoroughly the entire unit was embarrassed by Shanahan and friends.
Winters finished with a 29.0 PFF grade, posting three stops while missing two tackles and allowing four receptions on as many targets for 75 yards and a touchdown. Brock Purdy had a perfect passer rating (158.3) when targeting his former teammate.
James' 29.6 PFF grade wasn't much better. While he allowed just 17 yards in coverage, he struggled mightily against the run, routinely getting swallowed up by blockers at the second level and failing to capitalize on gaps created by Dallas' defensive line. He was also one of several Cowboys who struggled to contain Purdy.
Neither performance should come as a surprise. Winters has struggled in coverage all season, while James is still learning how to navigate traffic at the second level. The defense also looked confused before the snap on multiple occasions, which reflects poorly on James as the unit's primary communicator.
Both players have their limitations, and Dallas wasn't exactly overflowing with alternatives. Rookie Jaishawn Barham has been removed from the off-ball linebacker rotation, playing all 21 of his defensive snaps against San Francisco on the edge.
Purdy picked apart the middle of Dallas' defense all afternoon, while Overshown, who had made splash plays in consecutive games against the Eagles and Cardinals before missing Week 9, barely saw the field.
Granted, San Francisco presented a much tougher challenge than either Philadelphia or Arizona. But that only makes it more confounding that Overshown was never given a meaningful opportunity to make an impact.
Overshown's punishment didn't fit the crime
One could argue that missing curfew the night before a game is a much more serious step out of line than running onto the field to celebrate with your teammates. That isn't to diminish the stupidity of Overshown's decision, but it's fair to question the disparity in punishment.
Lamb and Pickens were held out for just one possession, while Overshown was effectively benched for an entire game. Schottenheimer deserves credit for holding his players accountable, and there's value in sending a message that even an emotional mistake can have consequences.
But given how San Francisco repeatedly tormented the middle of the field, it's worth wondering whether the message could have been delivered without keeping one of the team's better linebackers on the sideline for virtually the entire game.
Overshown practiced in full to close out the week and averaged 51 defensive snaps in his three previous appearances before playing just five (8 percent) on Sunday. When healthy, he's barely come off the field.
Assuming Overshown barely saw the field for disciplinary reasons, the punishment did not fit the crime. Bench him for the first drive. The first quarter, even.
Not the entire game.
