Skip to main content

7 undeniable positives on Cowboys' defense amid another dismal season

It's not all bad.
ByJerry Trotta
Dallas Cowboys defensive tackle Quinnen Williams
Dallas Cowboys defensive tackle Quinnen Williams | Cooper Neill/GettyImages

It's happening again. The Dallas Cowboys are in the midst of wasting a top-five offense and another Pro Bowl-caliber season from Dak Prescott. For the second year in a row, they are fielding arguably the NFL's worst defense that sinks to new lows every Sunday.

Is it possible to sink lower than allowing 46 yards, 9.8 yards per play and the most yards in franchise history at home? I'd like to say no, but that side of the ball has a way of disappointing even when expectations could be lower.

Your guess is as good as mine as to whether Christian Parker will be calling the defense this Sunday against the Titans. The defense needs yet another rebuild in the offseason, and while Dallas is still alive in the NFC East, it's not too soon to look to the future.

But instead of stewing in the negativity following the loss to San Francisco, there are players on the Cowboys' defense who deserve recognition for shining amid the rubble.

7 players who are shining on Cowboys' underachieving defense

1. Quinnen Williams is playing like the DPOY

The Cowboys' defensive rebuild has been an abject disaster, but they can hang their hat on trading for Quinnen Williams last November.

Williams got off to a slow start this season. Some questioned whether he was playing through an injury. As it turns out, it was the role Christian Parker was asking him to play. Now given the freedom to get upfield and do what he does best, Williams has been unblockable.

According to PFF, Williams recorded nine stops, one sack and a forced fumble against the 49ers. It was one of the best individual performances of any defensive player this season. Here's a look at where Williams ranks among his peers this season, via Sūmer Sports:

  • 47 impact plays: 1st 
  • 34 pressures: Tied for 3rd 
  • 6.0 sacks: 2nd 
  • 11 stuffed runs: 2nd 
  • 25 run stops: 1st 
  • 3 forced fumbles: 2nd

If the Cowboys were leading the NFC East with a winning record, Williams would absolutely be in Defensive Player of the Year conversations. He's an insane player, and, much like Dak Prescott and CeeDee Lamb, it's a shame that Dallas is wasting a year of his prime.

2. Joey Porter Jr. remains elite

The Cowboys don't have much going for them on defense, but they have studs in Williams and Porter Jr., who are two of the best players at their positions. That's a good starting point ... right?

Anyway, Porter has been better than advertised coming over from the Steelers. He has not prevented the rest of the ship from sinking, but that takes nothing away from how he's performed.

It was easy to miss as Kyle Shanahan and Co. hung 46 points on Dallas, but Porter was blameless in the loss. Brock Purdy did whatever he wanted in the game, but he was 0-for-2 targeting Porter. Like every other QB who has faced the Cowboys since Porter's arrival, Purdy simply decided to not even look his direction.

For the season, Porter has allowed just three catches for 19 yards and zero touchdowns on 19 targets. His 23.1 percent completion rate allowed is a staggering 16.9 percentage points lower than the next-closest cornerback. He's also second at the position in yards allowed per coverage snap (0.15) and first with just 1.46 yards allowed per target.

The Cowboys need to find a way to make the money work with him and George Pickens, but Porter is a rare player for his position who you can build your defense around.

3-5. Otito Ogbonnia, Elijah Garcia, LT Overton

The play of Quinnen Williams has understandably overshadowed the rest of the defensive tackle room. While Kenny Clark has endured an up-and-down campaign, Ogbonnia, Garcia and Overton have quietly emerged as bright spots.

We'll start with Ogbonnia, who is tied for fifth among DTs with 17 run stops. He doesn't play enough snaps to challenge for the league lead in impact plays and other major metrics, but he has vastly outperformed his $2 million in guaranteed money. He's one of the better value free-agent signings this team has made in recent memory.

The Cowboys' personnel department has really dropped the ball in recent drafts, but give them credit for finding Elijah Garcia right before the season. Despite joining a crowded room with multiple established vets, the 28-year-old Garcia has become a mainstay in the IDL rotation.

Garcia is currently tied for 14th (!) at the position with an 11.9 percent run-stop rate. He's compiled seven run stops on just 56 run-defense snaps. He's got six impact plays to his name, and his 10.3 percent pressure rate is inside the top 50. His emergence could give Dallas enough incentive to make Kenny Clark a cap casualty in the offseason, but we'll cross that bridge when we get there.

And speaking of pleasant surprises, how about L.T. Overton? The fourth-round pick out of Alabama doesn't get on the field often (he's played just 27 percent of the defensive snaps), but he's developed a knack for making plays in limited action.

Overton picked up the first sack of his career on Sunday. He actually failed to beat his matchup, but he showed great awareness and quickness to shed his block and corral Brock Purdy as he tried to escape the pocket. He also batted down a pass from the 49ers' quarterback.

The 22-year-old looks like he's going to be a player.

6. Caleb Downs will be a stud

Downs is coming off the worst game of his young career. He struggled mightily against the 49ers, missing multiple tackles, including one where Kaelon Black ran right through him on his touchdown run. He still led Dallas with 11 tackles, but his first encounter with Kyle Shanahan's offense was a humbling experience.

Having said that, Downs is still putting together an impressive rookie season. It's important to remember just how much the Cowboys have asked of him in his first year. He's been tasked with handling a variety of responsibilities, including playing significant snaps out of his natural position in the slot.

There have inevitably been growing pains, and Sunday's performance against the 49ers was a harsh reminder that Downs is still learning on the fly. But those struggles shouldn't overshadow the flashes of excellence he's shown or the fact that he's been one of the few bright spots on an otherwise disappointing defense.

Downs has as many impact plays as Packers star safety Xavier McKinney (14). He's also tied for second in sacks (two) and forced fumbles (two) and is tied for third with 13 run stops. He's already one of the more impactful players at his position.

He's going to be just fine.

7. Malachi Lawrence's flashes

Lawrence is currently on injured reserve with an ankle injury, in case you were wondering why the Cowboys' pass rush has been quieter than usual of late.

The No. 23 overall pick has not had a banner rookie year, but he was never expected to challenge for any hardware. Prior to getting hurt against the Cardinals in Week 8, Lawrence had forced his way into the starting lineup, taking Donovan Ezeiruaku's spot opposite Rashan Gary.

What you really wanted to see from Lawrence as a rookie was flashes, and he provided plenty over his first eight games, including a breakout game in Week 5, when he recorded multiple pressures, a sack and a pair of batted pressures.

The hope was that those flashes would eventually translate into more consistency, or at least more splash plays as the season progressed. Unfortunately, his injury robbed him of the opportunity to build on a promising start, but his flashes off the edge should have Cowboys fans excited about what he could become.

Add us as a preferred source on Google