Leave it to the Dallas Cowboys to discover that rock bottom has a basement. That's the prevailing sentiment surrounding the organization after Christian Parker was stripped of play-calling duties following Sunday's loss to the San Francisco 49ers.
Mike Pettine, who didn't join the Cowboys until October, will call the defense for the rest of the season, Brian Schottenheimer confirmed Wednesday. Parker, meanwhile, will retain his defensive coordinator title and continue leading meetings and playing a significant role in the weekly game plan.
Why Parker is being strung along instead of actually being fired is a question with a simple answer: Because it's the Cowboys. The entire process, starting with Schottenheimer's postgame takedown of Parker's defense, has felt slimy and messy.
Without further ado, let's get into the biggest winners and losers (mostly losers) of this team's latest debacle.
Biggest Cowboys winners and losers from Christian Parker's demotion
Loser: Jerry Jones
The Cowboys just do stuff. No plan. No process. They make it up as they go. Everything about the process that led to Parker's demotion was a masterclass in how not to run an NFL franchise.
Going on the radio to say that the team was evaluating Parker's role as the play-caller is organizational malpractice. If you've lost confidence in your defensive coordinator, make a decision behind closed doors. Don't publicly undermine him and then leave him hanging for 24 hours before actually demoting him. Intentional or not, that's messy.
Now, onto the decision to strip Parker of play-calling duties. Was the youngest defensive coordinator in franchise history not hired with a two-year plan in mind?
Parker has overseen an awful defense, and his inexperience and growing pains have been impossible to ignore. He obviously isn't absolved of blame. But what exactly did the Cowboys expect when they handed the keys to a 34-year-old who had never called plays at any level?
Keeping it a buck, Parker, while bad at his job, is taking the fall for organizational issues that festered long before his first season in the NFL in 2019. It all comes off as extremely snake-ish.
Jones rarely looks like a winner these days, but this is a really, really, really bad look for the team's foremost decision-maker.
Loser: Brian Schottenheimer
As bad a taste as it leaves in your mouth to see Parker scapegoated, effectively pre-fired and strung along, there's no denying that he wasn't ready to be a defensive coordinator.
But that falls squarely on Schottenheimer, who hand-picked Parker after an extensive search that included nine candidates. He knew he was hiring a 34-year-old first-time coordinator, and the growing pains that came with that decision should have been expected.
Among those candidates was Jonathan Gannon, who has turned the Packers into a top-10 defense in terms of EPA per play. While Green Bay's personnel is better than what Parker is working with, Gannon is going to end up with votes for Assistant Coach of the Year.
The Cowboys hired Parker on January 22. The Packers didn't hire Gannon, who had a second interview with Dallas, until January 27.
This team needed a DC with skins on the wall who could complement an offense that was already built to win. Instead, Schottenheimer, for whatever reason, chose the least experienced candidate despite knowing that he needed to win games in his second season at the helm.
Separate from that is the fact that Schottenheimer has overseen two of the worst defensive seasons in franchise history. A defense's play is a reflection of the head coach. And Dallas has done nothing but implode on that side of the ball during Schottenheimer's tenure.
Loser: Cowboys fans
Cowboys fans deserve a handwritten apology from the organization. They'll never get one, but this coaching shake-up is a new low for a franchise that has spiraled out of control following the Wild Card loss to the Green Bay Packers in 2023.
The Cowboys have ranked 30th, 32nd and 31st in points allowed per game dating back to 2024. Three different coordinators were in charge of those defenses: Parker (2026), Matt Eberflus (2025) and Mike Zimmer (2024). It seems likely that Parker will be fired after the season, but there's no evidence to suggest that will lead to improvements.
It will require a philosophical change from the organization. Whether it's hiring Brian Flores as head coach or finding a happy medium between experience and youthful innovation, it's time for the Cowboys to prioritize a clear vision and a coherent plan.
Unfortunately, that is a foreign language to Jerry Jones.
Loser: Mike Pettine
On one hand, Pettine is a winner for being handed the reins of the defense. On the other hand, Pettine is a loser for being handed the reins of the defense.
Pettine was enjoying retirement and vacationing in Italy with his wife when the Cowboys called about bringing him aboard as a senior assistant. Fast forward one month, and he's suddenly tasked with turning around arguably the worst defense in the NFL.
Talk about getting more than you bargained for.
Pettine signed up to be an experienced voice in Parker's corner, not to inherit the responsibility of fixing a historically bad defense midway through the season. Now, he'll be the one answering for a unit that seems unfixable.
That makes him a loser in this situation through no real fault of his own. Sipping on a beverage in the Italian sun probably doesn't sound too bad right now.
Winner: The players Malik Hooker did not throw under the bus
I had a feeling that Parker was in trouble when Malik Hooker was asked about the team's buy-in to what Parker is teaching.
“I can't speak on everybody," Hooker said. "I mean, I can only speak on me. I mean, for me, I think he's a great coach, does a great job out there, and I can only do what's asked of me. I mean, as far as everybody else, I'm not sure.”
There are parallels to Matt Eberflus' tenure last season. It was no secret inside the building that Eberflus had lost the locker room last season. There haven't been similar whispers about Parker, at least not publicly, but Hooker's comments suggested that at least a few players had begun to lose faith.
And the players Hooker did not implicate are the de facto winners of this ugly situation, having gotten a change at defensive play-caller without having to publicly question Parker themselves.
It had better result in a dramatic improvement, because the players are running out of people to blame for their own shortcomings.
