Where should Ezekiel Elliott rank among the NFL’s best running backs?

The Comparisons (5-1)

Being a top-five running back in the NFL is an amazing thing to accomplish, especially over a long time. Since entering the league, Zeke has been in this category.

The Tennessee Titans are so lucky to have a beast in Derrick Henry. Since entering the league he has tormented defenders as the best power rusher in the league. His role in the passing game is limited, but his excellence running makes up for it. Like Chubb, Henry should be a better receiver to be better overall.

The Saints have cherished Kamara’s ability to be a great pass catcher in a pass-heavy offense. He only averages around 250 touches per season, which is a ton less than Zeke’s 350. Because of that huge difference, looking at averages tells a much better story.

Over their careers, Zeke averages 4.6 yards per rush while Kamara averages 5.0 yards per rush. Meanwhile, as a receiver, Kamara beats Zeke with over 400 more receiving yards in one fewer season. Kamara has thrived on less usage, while Zeke has thrived on more usage.

ALSO READ: Dallas Cowboys: Will this be a bounce-back year for Ezekiel Elliott?

Imagine being a running back and placing second in receptions and being in the top 30 for receiving yards. Christian McCaffery did just that, being only the third player ever to post 1,000+ yards receiving and rushing. He had a ton of opportunity to do that with a league-leading 403 touches.

Running the ball, Zeke and McCaffery are close, with both being able to go around, through, or even over their opponent. As a receiver, CMC is like a wide receiver, while Zeke is underrated, but does have work to do.

Saquon Barkley has done a lot to earn his spot at the top of the list. Back to back 1,000+ yard rushing seasons and the ability to catch the ball for an average of just under 600 yards per season makes him an all-round headache. Not someone you want to go up against.

Comparing him to Zeke, they are both great runners, but Saquon’s great job as a receiver is what helps make him extra special. Some may argue Zeke is a better runner, some disagree.

I think no matter what, Ezekiel Elliott has to be in everyone’s top five. Based on how people value running backs will tell how high you put him.

Those that value cowbell running backs that pound away will have Zeke from first to third, while those that value dual threats will have him anywhere from the third to fourth. If you’re someone that thinks Zeke is outside the top ten, then you might need to go to the emergency room.

Player stats courtesy of Pro Football Focus