Sep 8, 2013; Arlington, TX, USA; Dallas Cowboys quarterback Tony Romo (9) reacts after the game against the New York Giants at AT

Stephen A. Smith: Cowboys 'Tony Romo is an Accident Waiting To Happen'


Part of the apparent job requirement on ESPN’s First Take is to stir up debate and controversy. And a constant topic of debate are the Dallas Cowboys, and particularly the play of quarterback Tony Romo. On Friday, co-host Stephen A. Smith replied to Cowboys legend Roger Staubach recent statement that Romo is a top five quarterback, by saying it’s “ridiculous”.

“How many times are we going to do this? Tony Romo puts up great numbers. Tony Romo is an impressive regular season quarterback. Tony Romo is entering his eighth year as the starting quarterback for the Dallas Cowboys. He has one playoff victory. And over the course of that time, he has proven to be an accident waiting to happen. He is what he is.”

Smith, an admitted New York Giants fan, has always been critical of Romo and his lack of postseason success. On one hand he complements Romo during this debate. And with the other, slaps him in the face verbally.

“Tony Romo can play. He is no scrub. I understand it. But stop trying to make him out to be more than he is. Tony Romo is a quality, skilled quarterback in this league. But when you are talking about the quarterback position, the one thing that matters above all else, is whether or not you’re a winner. And that is the one thing we can definitively say we will never accuse Tony Romo of being…just yet.”

Here’s what Staubach told USA Today about the current Cowboys quarterback:

“I personally think that Tony is a top five quarterback in the National Football League…He hasn’t had the good fortune that Troy (Aikman) and I had, as far as the stronger teams. Those who really understand what happens on the football field, and what it takes to make a good team, know you have to have a good quarterback. But you have to have the other pieces, also. If you look at Tony’s record and what he’s done…statistics don’t tell the story totally, but he’s been fantastic. He’s made big plays. He’s had some rough finishes, but that’s where the fan’s expectations are very high for the Dallas Cowboys.”

The other First Take co-host, Skip Bayless, a self-proclaimed Dallas Cowboys fan, defended Staubach’s statements saying Romo is an underrated quarterback but agreed with Smith saying we need to see more postseason success from him. Both men agreed that the Cowboys should defeat the San Diego Chargers this weekend due to the Chargers’ offensive line issues.

Smith ended the Romo discussion by saying:

“I’ve got the Dallas Cowboys winning this game (Chargers) 28-24. But what I’m saying to you is that it won’t be necessarily because of Tony Romo because that was how we started off and that’s how we jump-started this debate. Roger Staubach talking about Tony Romo as a top five quarterback in this game. I don’t see how anybody could come to that conclusion based on what they’ve seen.”

What do you think? Do you agree with Staubach? Is Tony Romo a top five quarterback in the NFL? Vote below:

Is Tony Romo currently a Top Five Quarterback in the NFL?

View Results

Loading ... Loading ...

Next Cowboys Game View full schedule »
Sunday, Sep 77 Sep3:25San Francisco 49ersBuy Tickets
Dick's Sporting Goods presents "Hell Week":

Tags: Dallas Cowboys First Take Roger Staubach Skip Bayless Stephen A. Smith Tony Romo

  • disqus_kLJwdEdnOL

    Quarterbacks need more than great talent to succeed in the NFL and writers who blame Romo for his team’s lack of success have little or no football knowledge or a personal vendetta. Personally, I usually don’t waste my time reading their articles. If they want to place blame for the Cowboy’s lack of success they need to write about the owner who has grossly mismanaged the team. Do most people think superbowl quarterback winner Joe Flacco is a top five quarterback?

  • ghostofakid

    Why would I tend to value Staubach’s assessment over that of a pencil neck fool?

  • prado209

    Stats point out individuals success. Wins and SB point out team success.

  • Juanito Juanito

    be real, i love romo but, to be in top 5 now is not possible, rodgers, brees, payton, brady, russell, and romo will fight with cuttler, matt ryan, and maybe some others, romo is a top ten qb until prove the opposite and the cowboys fans are waiting for it

  • Dallasiddue

    Look at what Eli is doing with an equivalent talent around him this year. OLine is way underated i think and given what Tony has had its been nothing short of amazing.