The Cowboys have played the game 4 times, so they will join that list above with 5 visits to Fawcett. The Cowboys visits to the Hall of Fame game happened in 1968, 1979, 1999, and 2010. They lost to the Bears in 1968, 24-30. They lost to the Oakland Raiders in 1979, 13-20. They lost to the Browns in 1999 in overtime, 17-20. They defeated the Cincinnati Bengals in 2010, 16-7. Thus their record in the game is a paltry 1-3. Yes, I do know pre-season games do not matter. I am just giving out the information.
The Dolphins have not fared much better. In fact they are tied with the Cowboys, Saints, and Bills for the most losses in the game with 3. Like the Bills the Dolphins are 0-3 in the game. They are 2 of the 5 teams who have never won the game. The other three are the San Diego Chargers, Houston Texans, and Jacksonville Jaguars, all of them are 0-1. In other words, a Dolphins loss to the Cowboys would put them all alone with 4 losses in the game.
While we mention lack of success in the game it probably is good to mention who has the most success. 4 teams have never lost the game. They are the Redskins, Bears, Raiders, and Carolina Panthers. The Redskins lead the pack with a 5-0 record, followed by the Bears at 4-0, the Raiders at 3-0, and the Panthers at 1-0. Every other team has at least 1 win and 1 loss.
The Dolphins previous trips to Fawcett Stadium were in 1978, 2001, and 2005. In 1978 they lost to the Philadelphia Eagles 3-17. In 2001 they lost to the Rams, 10-17. In 2005 they lost to the Bears 24-27.