Apr 26, 2012; New York, NY, USA; Members of the United States armed forces are honored during the 2012 NFL Draft at Radio City Music Hall. Mandatory Credit: James Lang-USA TODAY Sports

Should Dallas Move Down in the NFL Draft For More Picks?

One of the best things about working at the Landry Hat is experiencing the passion and intelligence of our Dallas Cowboys fans. And in an effort to further serve our great community, we put out a request this week to answer your fan questions.  So here is today’s question:

“Do you think we should trade back a few spots in the first round so we could have (more) picks in the first three rounds?” – Robert T.

What follows are the responses from some of our great staff writers and passionate Cowboy experts.

Mike Burke, Staff Writer – Robert, I would. I would rather have three picks in the 2nd (assuming 18 is traded for 2 of them) and our pick in the 3rd, than a 1st round pick. I like quality over quantity, except when you need quantity and the Draft has plenty of it at the holes you have, which in our case are both lines and Safety. So, yes, I would. Will they? I doubt it.

Kim Dunning, Senior Writer - If he was smart he would. The # 18 pick has never historically been good to the Cowboys. Last pick at # 18 was Bobby Carpenter. However, I don’t see him doing that, I do see Jerry as trading our picks to draft further up though.

Todd Toombs, Senior Writer – That is certainly an option that would make some sense – the draft is fairly deep where we have the most needs: offensive and defensive line. The later picks would cost us less in an already cap-constrained situation, but your odds of getting a quality player also go down exponentially outside of the first round. I wouldn’t rule it out, but I don’t think it will happen. Jerry will take the best offensive lineman on the board with the 18th pick and hope that solves the issues on the offensive front. I would expect this year to be a lot more conventional approach to the draft.

Michael Huff, Staff Writer - No.  It’s better to get the best player you can at 18 and I think they will stay where they are.  I see there being more of a chance they give up draft picks to move up to get Kenny Vacarro at safety.

Michael Vu, Staff Writer – The problem with finishing 8-8 is that it slaps us right in the middle. To answer your question, it depends who has left the board when the clock strikes Cowboys. I’m hoping the Cowboys can get a quality offensive lineman with their first pick. No need to be splashy and flashy. If we can’t get our man, let’s fall back a few spots and start filling up the holes with extra draft picks.

Renny Mason, Staff Writer – That remains a very high possibility Robert (and one I might vote for as well), as we all know Jerry has been known to wheel and deal on draft day. Our three biggest areas of need this off-season are of course offensive line, defensive line and safety. Lucky for us, the scouts are projecting great depth for all of these positions in this year’s draft class, therefore being able to find quality talent even in the later rounds. That means if they are not crazy about how the first 17 picks pan out, they can trade back a few spots, still pick up a quality starter at any of the three biggest need areas in the first round, and possibly add another 2nd or 3rd round pick from our trade partner.

Of course we will know our needs more when we get a little closer to the draft after we address a few areas in veteran free agency (cheap guys, don’t think Brandon Carr this year). The Cowboys have been very good the last several seasons about entering the draft without any glaring needs to fill, being able to fill most of those needs via free agency. Of course with this year’s cap situation, who knows. Either way, expect some combination of o-line, d-line and safety with the first two or three picks this April.

Next Cowboys Game View full schedule »
Sunday, Sep 77 Sep3:25San Francisco 49ersBuy Tickets
Dick's Sporting Goods presents "Hell Week":

Tags: Dallas Cowboys NFL Draft

  • Robert Turner

    Thank you all for picking my question to answer…Kool

  • californy

    It really doesnt mater where you pick , what matter is whom you pick. Many people here believe you can find value outside of the first round, unfortunately I never buy into the hype of round number one. The Boys will pay Anthony Spencer 10.6 Million for this year, that like paying Kuechey Salary like 11 times over and he led the NFl in Tackles last year. Kuechey is going to earn a base salary of 961,000 this year and he was drafted in rd number 1. Bobby Wagner had like 140 tackles last year he was chose in rd number 2, comparing him to Spencer, we could get 18 player with Bobby Wagner ability vs paying for 1 of Spencer. Vontaze Burflict went undrafted and he will make 480,00 this year and he had like 127 tackles. You can get two player with his ability that 254 tackles vs 164 that Kuechey had last year. So dont tell me there is no value outside of the first rd to make trading down worth it

    Here a possible trade down senario, Dallas 18 for Cincy 37 and 53 Pick. We then trade the 53 Pick for SF 20th and 31 th Pick in rd number 3. That gives us 5 picks in the top 94 Picks in the NFL draft. That is 5 picks of cap friendly number and 5 possible starters.

    • ctcowboy1968

      Sounds great on paper, my friend. But probably difficult to pull off in reality. You are absolutely right that it is who they pick, not where. But theoretically, there is less risk that one will get a high talent starter at 18 than at 84. We all know that quantity does not equal quality (see 2009 draft).

  • californy

    Here is some more value in last year rookie class Flemming LB for Indy went undrafted and he had like 145 tackles, last Year, Johnson CB for TB went undrafted and he had 41 tackles and 3 interception his rookie year, & he also made Aqib Expendable in TB.

  • http://twitter.com/OldFrog75 Old Frog

    Just the opposite. Trade 3-6 or 4-6 to move up.

  • ctcowboy1968

    Don’t trade up! Don’t draft Vaccaro. Stay at 18. Take in this order: Cooper, Warmack, Richardson, Fluter. All will be day 1 starters.

  • jrcowboy49

    Stay @18 and take Warmack/Cooper and Barrett Jones OC @ 49 wuold be great for our running and passing game. The last I looked, you have to score points to win.

  • Aaron Clark

    I’d like to see Dallas trade the first round pick for JAX’s 2nd, 3rd and 5th. Trade value is almost even with Dallas’s pick worth 900 points and JAX’s adding up to 894 points.