Seth Jones: I believe that overuse of the exotic defense is a recipe for disaster. If you bring the crazy out every 4 downs, as opposed to every other down, then the offense is still expecting the possibility of false reads. Exotic defensive plays are like lard. Yes, a few glasses of warm lard is delicious. But after consuming 4 gallons of it in under 30 minutes, it just becomes a problem.
C. Joseph Wright: Yes, I do think that Ryan’s defenses have looked much more conventional over the last month or so compared to what we saw in September. I have also noticed that the number of substitutions has also seemed to decrease. As some of you likely know already, I have commented about these phenomena in my weekly articles for the last few weeks. Every time I watch a Rob Ryan interview, I keep expecting someone to ask him, “Why?”, but no one ever does. To my knowledge, Ryan has never publicly addressed the issue. I have to admit: I am stumped; I have no idea why. Every week I keep hoping to see the “chaos” we saw in September, but every week I am disappointed. Since I do not have a reasonable explanation, I am going to tell you what I HOPE it is.
I hope that Ryan’s recent tendency to play a more ‘vanilla’ defense without all the pre-snap motion that confuses OL’s and QB’s and disguised coverages that confuse WR’s and QB’s is because he figured that his defense was good enough to beat the last 4 opponents without getting complicated. I am hoping that he is “saving” all the unusual formations and ‘chaos’ for the teams like the Giants that have a much more talented offense. Perhaps he did not want to ‘tip his hand’ to the OC’s of teams like the Giants and Eagles.
If I am correct, we will see the defense go back to the ‘chaos’ of massive substitution, unusual coverages, and a flurry of pre-snap motion this week. If I am wrong, then we will likely continue to see a fairly conventional scheme from Ryan.
To answer your last question, I sure hope that the basic schemes and game-plans change down the stretch. Given the mediocre performance of the defense over the last month, one would expect that Ryan will have something new for the Giants.
If you have questions that you would like us to answer, please email your query to firstname.lastname@example.org